I’ve just completed my first year as city editor at The Gazette, my first year of living in Gastonia, and it’s been a year of de-je vu.
Why am I getting these flashbacks, you ask? OK, I must confess, this isn’t my first stint at The Gazette, or as a resident of Gastonia. I lived here for five years in the late 1980s and early 1990s. It’s amazing how the problems of 18-20 years ago are the same problems facing the city today.
One of those problems is downtown. It was plagued by vacancies and failed startups then, just like it is now. But unlike 20 years ago, downtown Gastonia now has at least a sliver of hope for the future. Just in the year I have been here, I’ve seen a lot of activity: artists creating public art, developers redeveloping old commercial buildings into living quarters, and a Charlotte businessman converting the historic Webb Theater into a restaurant. And, of course, it’s hard to miss the sight of a $25 million conference center now rising at the corner of Marietta Street and Franklin Boulevard.
While the risks are obvious, it looks like the central city could be poised for a renaissance, and I am cautiously optimistic, which is something I couldn’t have said in 1990.
Yet, with all these signs pointing towards hope, all you read is negativity from readers who post online comments about the downtown stories we’ve reported in The Gazette. It’s all doomed to failure, they predict.
This sounds strange and unfamiliar to me. Most places I’ve lived seek the best, wish for the best, for their central city, their “main drag” or whatever you want to call it. Then de-je vu strikes and I remember, this is Gastonia. This is exactly how is was 20 years ago. Different people, same opinions. Perhaps these feelings of negativity toward anything downtown were passed on to them by their parents? I don’t know, but the feelings are strongly held.
I wonder if these folks ever feel even a small tinge of jealousy when they visit, say, Greenville, S.C., or some other Southern city that has managed to retain an actual working downtown in spite of the growth of suburban areas? Are they against downtowns in general or only Gastonia’s downtown?
Many point out that they are not rooting for downtown Gastonia to fail, they simply wish that city government would stop intervening on its behalf. They say downtown should be allowed to succeed or fail on its own merits. Let the free market determine its fate, they argue.
That sounds good in principle but is it realistic? The city doesn’t “throw money” at downtown any more than it has thrown money at other areas to encourage development. Just one, striking example of this is the City Council’s decision to pay $3.1 million for the construction of an access road for the new Target discount store at Gaston Mall. The money will come from retail sales and property taxes generated from the new development.
Likewise, the money for grants given to startup businesses downtown comes from a tax levied only on downtown businesses. This seems like a fair use of tax dollars to me.
Let it be noted, too, that the problems that plague downtown are now spreading to the east side of town. When Target moves to its bigger, newer, nicer store at Gaston Mall, it will leave behind a gaping hole on New Hope Road, next to another empty store recently vacated by TJ Maxx. Those “dark” spaces join a growing list that includes two Circuit City stores, Backyard Burger and others. Pretty soon the east side of town will be looking pretty old and out of fashion, too. Maybe then downtown won’t look so bad and may even begin to look good once the new projects at the Webb and the conference center are done.
As my grandmother used to say, “what goes around comes around.”